I must say, when the announcement of Finale being killed off by MakeMusic made me mad. It was an EXCELLENT piece of software. I’ve been using it since version 2.5 (on floppy disks). I have thousands (tens of maybe) of files I’ve done in Finale. I know the program like the back of my hand.
But, it had not been moving forward for a while. It’s mature, stable for what it is. It works. However, the computers it runs on are not staying put. Apple and Microsoft are changing their OSes all the time. Apple has set a hard date of next year (2027) as the death of Finale (and many other apps). Microsoft…..Finale might run a bit longer on it. But at some point a Windows update will either kill it or it will have issues.
Enter the replacements. The best one so far is the FREE Maestro App (Windows and macOS). I must say, this app is excellent. It opens Finale musx files. It generally opens everything I have…..except…..files with custom articulations (which is most of them). I imagine that it will, soon, open those files as well. This is really THE replacement for Finale right now. It gets better in every version, and versions are coming frequently.
Another successor is Notalia. This program is in beta, and it looks amazing too. It does NOT open musx files as well as Maestro. Anything with lyrics…..they don’t show up. The formatting is bad. But it is in BETA and visually it is stunning.
If I was starting a new project would I use these? Probably not. Honestly, I’m totally happy with Dorico. The output is just….amazing. Music looks like art from this program. And doing big projects (band arrangements, etc) is a breeze with Dorico. And the parts are just……amazing looking as well. They are all uniformly formatted and I don’t have to mess with them.
Maestro, if they add something to put notenames ON TOP of notes, I would totally use for simple teaching sheets. Or simple lead sheets for students of their favorite pop song.
Honestly, I was dreading having to convert all my musx files into musicXML files and converting them to Dorico. I’ve done a lot of them, but….it’s a pain. Now, I do not have to. I can keep Finale running until the next macOS version, then switch to using Maestro. It’s good to see people creating amazing new apps with or without AI. If AI is helping them to it, then I am totally fine with that.
Check out those two apps if you are a Finale user or ex-user.



